The Most Terrifying Ways to Die in the Middle Ages and the People Put To Death

On a November afternoon in 1290, a Welshman called William Cragh was hanged on a hill outside Swansea, in full view of the castle. The man hanged beside him was so big, and struggled so hard, that the crossbeam of the gallows snapped. 

They strung both men up a second time. Cragh was cut down at about four o’clock and carried into town, for all intents and purposes dead. But the next day he started breathing again.

He lived at least another 18 years, and in 1307 he told his story to a team of papal investigators in Hereford, and there are many more tales, some too gruesome to read, others too strange to believe, but they happened in the Middle Ages.

A stylized woodcut shows a kneeling man about to be beheaded in front of a crowd and religious figures, illustrating the formal and often ceremonial nature of capital punishment in medieval Europe.
Add Tales of the Middle Ages to Google:

Hanging: The Death Almost Anyone Could Face

Dozens of bodies hang from the limbs of a large tree as soldiers and townsfolk look on, showing the widespread and public nature of hanging as a common execution method in medieval times.
Photo Credit: Photos.com/Getty Images

Hanging was the everyday punishment of medieval England. Most felonies carried the death penalty, and stealing anything worth a shilling, 12 pence, or more counted as a felony. A sheep or a good cloak could be enough.

There was no drop and no trapdoor. The condemned were pulled up or pushed off a ladder or cart and left to strangle, which could take several minutes. Gallows usually stood outside the town, on a hill or at a crossroads, where travelers couldn’t miss them.

That slow strangling is why William Cragh survived. His case is told in full in Robert Bartlett’s book The Hanged Man. Cragh had been captured by the lord of Gower, William de Briouze, and accused of killing 13 men during a Welsh revolt. 

His friends offered a hundred cows to buy his life, but de Briouze refused. The lord even forced one of Cragh’s own relatives to act as hangman.

What saved Cragh, as far as anyone at the time was concerned, was de Briouze’s wife, Lady Mary. She prayed to the late Bishop of Hereford, Thomas de Cantilupe, to bring him back. When Cragh recovered, it was put forward as one of Cantilupe’s miracles in the case to make him a saint. 

The papal commissioners ultimately rejected that miracle. Cantilupe was made a saint anyway, in 1320.

Most people weren’t so lucky. Some bodies were left hanging in chains on a gibbet for months as a warning, and the crows did the rest.

Beheading: Who Got the Axe?

A medieval executioner raises a sword above a kneeling woman, moments before beheading her, as onlookers in period attire watch solemnly—an example of one of the more "noble" ways to die in the Middle Ages.

Beheading was the death of the nobility. It was meant to be quick, and it spared a man of rank the shame of the rope. Whether it was quick depended entirely on the person holding the axe.

Sometimes nobody would hold it at all. 

In March 1330,  Edmund of Woodstock, Earl of Kent, was condemmed as a traitor. He was the son of Edward I and the uncle of the young Edward III. He’d been tricked into a plot to free his half-brother, Edward II, who was almost certainly already dead. Many believe the trap was set by Roger Mortimer and Queen Isabella, who were running the country.

Edmund was led out at Winchester Castle on March 19, 1330. And then everyone waited. Nobody wanted to be the man who cut off the head of a king’s son. It took hours to find someone. In the end, a convicted murderer who cleaned the latrines agreed to do it, in return for his own pardon.

Edmund had begged to be allowed to walk from Winchester to London with a rope around his neck instead. Mortimer refused. Within the year, Edward III had Mortimer arrested and hanged at Tyburn. Not beheaded. Hanged, like a common thief, which tells you exactly what the young king thought of him.

Hanged, Drawn and Quartered: The Death Saved for Traitors

A series of illustrations shows a condemned man being paraded, hanged, disemboweled, and ultimately quartered by horses, detailing the gruesome process of drawing and quartering as a method of execution in the Middle Ages.
Photo Credit: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

This was the worst sentence English law could give a man, reserved for high treason. The prisoner was dragged to the place of execution, hanged until nearly dead, cut down, disemboweled, beheaded and cut into four. The pieces were sent off around the kingdom to be put on show.

The first well-known man to die this way was Welsh. Dafydd ap Gruffydd, brother of Llywelyn, the last native Prince of Wales, led the final Welsh war against Edward I. On October 3, 1283, at Shrewsbury, he was dragged through the streets behind a horse, hanged, revived, disemboweled, and quartered. 

He’s also the first person known to have been tried and executed for treason against the king.

Twenty-two years later, Edward I did it again. William Wallace was captured near Glasgow in 1305 and taken to London. On August 23, 1305, he was dragged to Smithfield and put to death the same way. 

His head went up on London Bridge, and the four quarters of his body were sent to Newcastle, Berwick, Stirling and Perth.

Edward wanted Wallace forgotten. Instead, the Scots got a martyr, and seven centuries later we got Braveheart.

The parts were sent to different cities and nailed up on gates and bridges as permanent warnings. There’s no better-known example than William Wallace, the Scottish freedom fighter turned national legend. In 1305, after years of leading resistance against English rule, Wallace was captured and handed over to Edward I. 

Wallace was dragged through London in chains, jeered at by crowds, then subjected to the full ritual. Hanged until nearly dead, disemboweled, beheaded, and quartered. His head was stuck on a spike on London Bridge, and his limbs sent to Newcastle, Berwick, Stirling, and Perth—the corners of the rebellion, now pinned with parts of its leader.

His execution didn’t have the effect Edward hoped for. Instead of silencing resistance, it made Wallace a martyr. But the method stuck. For the next few centuries, anyone labeled a traitor to the crown could expect the same.

Burning at the Stake: Heretics and Women

Two men, identified as Ridley and Latimer, are tied to wooden stakes surrounded by kindling, while a large crowd watches their burning—one of the most agonizing ways to die in the Middle Ages for heresy.
Photo Credit: Fototeca Gilardi/Getty Images

Fire was the punishment for heresy. The idea was that it destroyed the body completely, leaving nothing to bury and nothing to keep as a relic. In England, it was also how women convicted of treason died, because drawing and quartering a woman was seen as indecent. Burning her alive apparently wasn’t.

The two most famous medieval burnings both happened in France.

On March 18, 1314, Jacques de Molay, the last Grand Master of the Knights Templar, was burned on a little island in the Seine, within sight of Notre-Dame. He’d just taken back his confession and declared the Templars innocent. 

Legend says he called on King Philip IV and Pope Clement V to meet him before God within the year. Clement died that April and Philip that November, which is how the Templar curse was born.

Then, on May 30, 1431, Joan of Arc was burned in the old marketplace at Rouen. She was about 19. The Burgundians captured her and sold her to the English during the Hundred Years’ War, then a church court tried her for heresy. 

They threw her ashes into the Seine, and if you ever visit Rouen, a tall cross marks the spot in the Place du Vieux-Marché. 

The great witch burnings most people think of came later. The worst witch trials happened in the 1500s and 1600s, after the Middle Ages ended.

She was a warrior, a visionary, and a threat. After leading French forces to key victories during the Hundred Years’ War, Joan was captured by the Burgundians and handed over to the English. They didn’t just want her dead; they wanted her discredited.

Her trial was a farce. She was charged with heresy for wearing men’s clothing, claiming to hear saints, and taking up arms. When she refused to back down, they lit the fire. In 1431, she was burned at the stake in Rouen’s market square. She was nineteen. Eyewitnesses said the crowd wept. 

Joan’s case wasn’t unique, though. Thousands met the same end across Europe. Some were healers accused of witchcraft. Others were reformers, thinkers, or simply unlucky. In Germany, Switzerland, and parts of France, the flames kept burning well into the early modern period.

The Wheel: What Did Breaking on the Wheel Mean?

A man lies sprawled on a large wooden wheel platform as an executioner raises a club to break his limbs, a brutal form of death known as breaking on the wheel in medieval Europe.
Photo Credit: Photos.com/Getty Images

The wheel was used mostly in France, the Low Countries, and the German lands, usually on murderers and highway robbers. England never really took to it. The executioner smashed the prisoner’s arms and legs with a heavy wheel or an iron bar, and the broken body was often woven through the spokes and raised on a pole to be seen.

For a long time, we had the law books and the pictures but very little hard evidence. Then, in 2019, scientists from the University of Milan published a study of a skeleton dug up in the square of Sant’Ambrogio in Milan, dated between 1290 and 1430. 

He was a young man, aged 17 to 20. His forearms and legs had been broken by blows struck straight on, and he had injuries to his face and skull. The researchers concluded he had probably been broken on the wheel.

He was also unusually small for his age. The team wondered whether he’d been picked on for being different, perhaps even blamed for spreading plague.

One of the most disturbing cases was Peter Niers, a man accused of black magic and hundreds of murders in the late sixteenth century. His crimes may have been exaggerated, but his execution was anything but. He was tortured for days with hot pincers, beaten, and then broken on the wheel. His death was dragged out to match the fear he inspired.

In France and across the Holy Roman Empire, the wheel was often used to punish robbers and bandits, especially if their crimes were violent. It wasn’t for nobles or traitors. It was the punishment for those who disrupted the peace in the forests and along the roads. 

In some cases, the executioner was allowed to give a final blow to the head or chest to end the suffering. But that was optional. Mercy didn’t always come. Afterward, the wheel was left on display with the remains still tangled in it, a grim warning to anyone passing by. 

Impalement: Vlad the Impaler and the Stories About Him

A chaotic medieval scene features a man being impaled with a long spear while a crowd gathers, reflecting one of the most excruciating and torturous ways to die in the Middle Ages.
Photo Credit: Photos.com/Getty Images

Impalement was rare in Western Europe. It belongs to the East, and above all to Vlad III of Wallachia, who ruled on and off between 1448 and 1476 and later lent his name to Dracula.

Vlad did impale his enemies, Ottoman soldiers and his own nobles among them, as a warning. But the numbers grew with every telling. 

Many of the worst stories come from German pamphlets printed in the 1460s, the tabloids of their day, written by people with every reason to make him look like a monster. 

One famous tale says he nailed Ottoman envoys’ turbans to their heads because they wouldn’t take them off. I’d take that one with a pinch of salt.

Vlad III of Wallachia, also known as Vlad the Impaler, was the most notorious figure associated with this method. He ruled in the mid-1400s and is often remembered as the inspiration for Dracula, but the real man was far more terrifying than any vampire story. His kingdom sat between Christian Europe and the Muslim Ottoman Empire, and he was constantly at war.

Vlad used impalement as a weapon of fear. He reportedly ordered thousands of people impaled at once, lining roads with stakes so that enemy armies would think twice before marching any further. One story tells of Ottoman envoys who refused to remove their turbans in his court. Vlad had the turbans nailed to their skulls. Another tells of a field filled with twenty thousand corpses, each one skewered and rotting in the sun.

The historical numbers may be exaggerated, but the fear was real. A warning. A show of force that said, this land belongs to me, and this is what happens when you cross me.

Drowning: Pit and Gallows

Dramatic engraving from Cassell’s Illustrated History of England showing the execution of George Plantagenet, Duke of Clarence, being drowned in a butt of Malmsey wine by three men, as onlookers watch.
Engraving from Cassell’s Illustrated History of England showing the execution of George Plantagenet, Duke of Clarence

In medieval Scotland, a baron with full powers of justice held the right of “pit and gallows.” The gallows were for men. The pit, a pool of water, was for women, who were usually drowned rather than hanged. Nobody’s quite sure why, but decency seems to have played a role.

Drowning could also be a favor. In 1526, a Scottish thief who’d robbed a church was drowned rather than hanged “by the queen’s special grace.”

Then there’s England’s most famous drowning, which may never have happened. George, Duke of Clarence, brother of Edward IV and future Richard III, was condemned for treason and executed privately in the Tower on February 18, 1478. 

The story that he was drowned in a butt of Malmsey wine was going around within a few years. It may even be true. Either way, it’s the death everyone remembers him for.

Rank Decided How You Died

You don’t have to be a genius to work out the order of things. A noble lost his head, a thief swung from a rope, a traitor was torn apart, and a woman who committed the same crime was burned or drowned. The punishment depended as much on who you were as on what you’d done.

It didn’t really change under the Tudors, either. Tudor executions were every bit as brutal, from the botched beheading of Margaret Pole to Robert Aske hanging in chains at York, and rank still decided how a traitor died.

As for William Cragh, not many people in history can say they died on a hill above Swansea and got up again the next day.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the most common way to be executed in the Middle Ages?

Hanging was the most common method of execution in medieval England and much of Europe. It was used for ordinary felonies, including theft of goods worth 12 pence or more. There was no drop, so the condemned died slowly by strangulation. Beheading was mostly kept for nobles, and burning for heretics and for women convicted of treason.

Who was the first person to be hanged, drawn, and quartered?

Dafydd ap Gruffydd, brother of Llywelyn, the last native Prince of Wales, was the first prominent person executed by being hanged, drawn, and quartered. He was put to death at Shrewsbury on October 3, 1283, on the orders of Edward I. William Wallace suffered the same fate in London on August 23, 1305.

Were witches burned in the Middle Ages?

Some witches were burned in the Middle Ages, but the great European witch hunts happened mostly in the 1500s and 1600s, after the medieval period. In medieval Europe, burning was used mainly for heresy. Famous medieval burnings include Jacques de Molay, the last Templar Grand Master, in 1314, and Joan of Arc in 1431.

Was the Duke of Clarence really drowned in a barrel of wine?

Nobody knows if George, Duke of Clarence, really drowned in a barrel of wine. He was executed privately in the Tower of London on February 18, 1478, after being condemned for treason against his brother Edward IV. The story that he was drowned in a butt of Malmsey wine spread within a few years of his death, but no eyewitness account survives.

Did anyone survive a medieval hanging?

Yes. William Cragh was hanged outside Swansea in 1290 and revived the next day. Medieval hangings had no drop, so death came slowly, and some people were cut down before they had died. Cragh’s recovery was presented as a miracle of Thomas de Cantilupe, Bishop of Hereford, and he lived at least another 18 years.

Promotional banner for a Medieval Survival Quiz with bold text asking, "Would You Survive the Middle Ages?" and "Which Medieval Class Would You Belong To? Prove Thy Worth." Features vintage-style illustrations of a knight, a noblewoman, an archer, and other medieval figures, along with a scroll-shaped button reading "Take the Quiz."