What History Got Wrong About Mary Boleyn: The Other Boleyn Sister Who Outlived Them All

If you’ve watched The Other Boleyn Girl, you probably think you know Mary Boleyn. She’s the sweet sister the king used and threw away, the one who ran to the Tower to beg for Anne’s life. It’s a cracking film, I’ll give it that. But most of what it tells you about Mary is invented.

So who was the real Mary Boleyn? She was Anne’s big sister, and for a few years in the early 1520s she was Henry VIII’s mistress, long before Anne ever caught his eye. She married twice, the second time for love, which caused no end of trouble. Her two children did very nicely for themselves under Elizabeth I, and Mary died quietly in 1543 with none of the drama that followed her siblings. And here’s the bit I love: King Charles III is her direct descendant.

What makes her interesting isn’t the scandal, but the fact she was the only Boleyn sibling who walked away from court on her own terms, and lived.

She left almost no paper trail, though. The late Tudor historian Eric Ives once said that everything we know about Mary would fit on a postcard with space to spare. So I’ve gone back to what the records say. Where they’re silent, I’ll tell you so.

Promotional graphic for an article or documentary titled ‘What History Got Wrong About Mary Boleyn: The Forgotten Sister of Anne, Mistress, Mother, Survivor.’ The image highlights Mary Boleyn’s underestimated role in Tudor history.
Scarlett Johansson playing Mary Boleyn in The Other Boleyn Girl
Add Tales of the Middle Ages to Google:

Who Was Mary Boleyn?

Mary Boleyn was the eldest daughter of Thomas Boleyn, a clever and ambitious diplomat, and Elizabeth Howard. Her mother’s family was among England’s most powerful nobles, so the Duke of Norfolk was her uncle.

The Key Facts We Know About Mary Boleyn

  • Born: around 1499, probably at Blickling Hall in Norfolk
  • Siblings: Anne Boleyn and George Boleyn
  • First husband: William Carey, married February 4, 1520
  • Second husband: William Stafford, married secretly in 1534
  • Children: Catherine Carey, born about 1524, and Henry Carey, born March 4, 1526
  • Died: July 1543, probably at Rochford Hall in Essex

She grew up in Kent and Norfolk and learned what every well-born girl should: music, dancing, needlework, how to run a household, and enough French to serve a queen. That French would come in handy sooner than anyone expected.

Was Mary Boleyn Older Than Anne?

Yes, Mary Boleyn was almost certainly older than her sister Anne. And it clears up the muddle over her age that you’ll find in a lot of retellings.

Mary married first, in 1520, and the eldest daughter usually married first. The stronger clue came 54 years after her death. In 1597, her grandson George Carey, 2nd Baron Hunsdon, petitioned Lord Burghley for the Boleyn earldom of Ormond, arguing that his grandmother was the elder daughter. 

If Anne had been the elder, her daughter, Queen Elizabeth I, would have inherited the claim. It’s hard to believe the Careys would make that claim to Elizabeth’s face if it weren’t true.

A few historians still argue the other way, but if Mary was born around 1499, everything else falls into place. She was about 15 when she sailed for France in 1514 and about 22 at the famous court pageant of 1522. By then, she was no longer a young teenager but a married woman.

Did Mary Boleyn Have an Affair With the King of France?

Probably not, and any evidence is shaky at best. As with so many things like this, we can’t say for sure, as we weren’t there.

In the autumn of 1514, Mary joined the household of the king’s sister, Mary Tudor, who sailed to France to marry the aging Louis XII. Louis died on January 1, 1515, less than three months after the wedding. Mary Tudor went home.

Painting of Francis I of France, wearing an elaborate embroidered doublet and feathered hat. Mary Boleyn was rumored to have had an affair with him during her time at the French court.
Francois I By Jean Clouet

Mary Boleyn seems to have stayed on, most likely in the household of Queen Claude, the wife of the new king, Francis I, who’d grown up at the Château d’Amboise in the Loire Valley.

Mary’s reputation comes from one letter. In March 1536, the papal nuncio Rodolfo Pio, Bishop of Faenza, reported that Francis had called Anne’s sister a great whore, infamous above all others. Historians have repeated the slur for 150 years. But look at the problems:

  • It’s secondhand. Pio wrote down what he says Francis told him more than 20 years later.
  • Pio was a Catholic churchman with every reason to blacken the Boleyns, who had helped Henry break with Rome.
  • The same letter claims Anne faked a miscarriage in 1536 with only her sister in attendance. Anne really did miscarry that January, and Mary had been banished from court two years earlier.
  • The historian Sylvia Barbara Soberton went back to the original Italian and found that Pio never names Mary at all. The English translators added her name.

So I’m inclined to file this one under Tudor gossip. Mary came home to England around 1519, and if she brought a reputation back with her, nobody at the English court wrote it down.

When Did Mary Boleyn Become Henry VIII’s Mistress?

No one knows the exact date, but clues point to roughly 1522 to 1525, while she was married to William Carey.

Mary married Carey, a gentleman of the king’s privy chamber, on February 4, 1520, at Greenwich, with Henry VIII himself at the wedding. It was a good match for a girl whose father was still climbing.

Then the gifts started. A review of the royal records shows that Henry granted William Carey a string of lands and offices from at least February 1522 to May 1526. Kings didn’t usually reward a husband that generously for nothing. Henry also owned a ship called the Mary Boleyn in the early 1520s. Make of that what you will.

Formal portrait of William Carey in Tudor attire, with fur-trimmed sleeves and a coat of arms in the background. William was Mary Boleyn’s husband and courtier to Henry VIII.
William Carey

The Château Vert Pageant of 1522

On Shrove Tuesday, March 4, 1522, Cardinal Wolsey staged a pageant at York Place, his London palace, for the visiting ambassadors of Emperor Charles V. 

A green wooden castle stood in the great chamber, with towers and banners. Eight ladies stood inside, each playing a virtue, her name embroidered in gold on her gown. 

The king’s sister Mary Tudor played Beauty. Jane Parker, the future wife of George Boleyn, played Constancy. Anne Boleyn played Perseverance. Mary Boleyn played Kindness.

Henry led a band of lords to storm the castle. The ladies defended it by pelting them with rose water and sweets, and the lords hit back with dates and oranges. Then everyone unmasked and danced. I’d have paid good money to see that.

Historians often link this night to the start of the affair with Mary. The TV series The Tudors uses it as the night Henry falls for Anne instead. Neither can be proven.

The Proof Henry Couldn’t Hide

So how do we know the affair happened at all? Because Henry himself admitted it, in a roundabout way.

In 1527, when he wanted to marry Anne, he asked the Pope for a dispensation to marry a woman with whom he had a relationship of affinity in the first degree through illicit intercourse. In plain English, he’d slept with her sister. 

Years later, Sir George Throckmorton told Henry that people said he’d been with both Anne’s mother and her sister. Henry’s reply? “Never with the mother.”

Well, that settles it.

And here’s the irony. Henry was busy telling the world that his marriage to Catherine of Aragon was cursed because she’d been his brother’s wife. At the same time, he quietly asked the Pope to excuse almost the same thing for Anne. You couldn’t make it up.

Was Henry VIII the Father of Mary Boleyn’s Children?

Henry VIII may have fathered Mary Boleyn’s children, but no one has proven it, and Henry never said so. Mary’s daughter Catherine was born around 1524, and her son Henry was born on March 4, 1526, four years to the day after the Château Vert pageant. 

Both arrived during the years Henry was showering William Carey with grants.

Henry was not shy about bastards he believed were his. He made Henry FitzRoy, his son by Bessie Blount, a duke at the age of six. He gave the Carey children nothing like that.

There’s one contemporary hint. On April 20, 1535, John Hale, the vicar of Isleworth, told the King’s Council that a man had shown him young Henry Carey and called him the king’s son by the queen’s sister. Two weeks later Hale was hanged at Tyburn for denying the king’s supremacy, so he was hardly a calm or impartial witness, poor man.

I’m inclined to think either child could have been Henry’s. But without a word from the king, it stays a maybe.

Portrait of Catherine Carey, daughter of Mary Boleyn, dressed in richly embroidered Tudor clothing and holding a small dog. As Mary Boleyn’s child, Catherine’s lineage remains a key part of royal ancestry debates.
Catherine Carey By Steven van der Meulen — Yale Center for British Art
Tudor-era portrait of Henry Carey in dark velvet robes with a ruff collar and a gold medallion. Henry was the son of Mary Boleyn, and speculation continues over whether he was actually the child of Henry VIII.
Henry Carey By Steven van Herwijck — Weiss Gallery

How Did Anne Boleyn Treat Her Sister Mary?

Better than the novels suggest, at least at first. In June 1528, the sweating sickness swept through England, and William Carey died of it. Mary was left a widow with two small children and very little money. Her father did nothing. 

By now deep in his pursuit of Anne, Henry wrote to her that Thomas Boleyn must provide for his daughter in her extreme need.

Henry gave Anne the wardship of little Henry Carey, and Anne paid for her nephew’s fine education. Mary got an annuity to live on. That doesn’t sound like two sisters at war. 

Anne and Mary’s relationship only broke down later, and Mary’s heart broke it.

Why Was Mary Boleyn Banished From Court?

Mary was banished from court in 1534 because she married for love, and nobody asked the queen.

William Stafford was a younger son of a good family with no money to speak of. He served as a gentleman usher to the king and a soldier in the garrison at Calais. Mary married him in secret, and the secret came out when she fell pregnant.

Anne was now queen and furious. A Boleyn married to a penniless soldier was an embarrassment, and a wasted chance at a useful alliance. Mary and her new husband were sent away from court, and her family cut her off.

Then Mary did something remarkable. She wrote to Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, and asked him to plead her case with the king, the queen, her parents, her uncle Norfolk, and her brother George. But she didn’t apologize for the marriage. 

She told Cromwell she would “rather beg my bread with him than to be the greatest queen christened.”

It’s the only time we hear Mary in her own words, and she doesn’t sound sorry one bit. Given what happened to the greatest queen christened two years later, it’s hard not to shiver.

Side-by-side portraits of Anne Boleyn and Mary Boleyn, both wearing pearl-adorned Tudor headdresses. The image contrasts the more famous Anne with her older sister Mary, whose story is often overlooked in Tudor history.
Anne Boleyn on the left and Mary Boleyn on the right

Where Was Mary Boleyn When Anne Was Executed?

Mary was nowhere near the Tower when Anne was executed, as far as anyone can tell.

In May 1536, Anne and George were arrested and charged with adultery, incest, and treason. George was executed on May 17, and Anne two days later, on May 19. No surviving record puts Mary at the trials, or anywhere near court.

The scene where Mary rushes to Henry to beg for her sister’s life and carries off little Elizabeth comes from Philippa Gregory’s novel and the film it inspired. It’s powerful drama, but it’s also fiction.

Mary kept her head down, and she kept her head because of it. When her father died in 1539, she inherited part of the Boleyn lands, including Rochford Hall in Essex, and lived there quietly with Stafford.

Dramatic re-enactment of Anne Boleyn’s execution, showing a solemn young woman in Tudor dress kneeling on the scaffold as her ladies prepare her. This scene ties closely to Mary Boleyn’s legacy, as Anne’s tragic end deeply impacted the Boleyn family.
Claire Foy playing Anne Boleyn in Season 1 of Wolf Hall

When and Where Did Mary Boleyn Die?

Mary Boleyn died in July 1543, either on the 19th or the 30th, at about 44. She most likely died at Rochford Hall. No record of the cause survives.

Nobody knows where she’s buried, either. No tomb, no marker, no monument. For the woman whose descendants now sit on the throne, that’s a rather sad gap.

What Happened to Mary Boleyn’s Children?

Both of Mary’s children did very well indeed, thanks to their cousin, Queen Elizabeth I.

Catherine Carey, Lady Knollys

Catherine married Sir Francis Knollys in 1540. When Elizabeth I came to the throne, she made Catherine her Chief Lady of the Bedchamber, the most trusted of all her ladies-in-waiting.

Catherine died at Hampton Court on January 15, 1569. A grief-stricken Elizabeth paid £640 2s 11d for her funeral at Westminster Abbey. That was a bloody fortune then. 

Her monument in St Edmund’s Chapel still names her mother as the Lady Mary, sister to Queen Anne.

Henry Carey, Lord Hunsdon

Henry did even better. In the first weeks of her reign, Elizabeth made him Baron Hunsdon. He served her as a soldier, a privy councilor and, from 1585, Lord Chamberlain of her household.

And here’s my favorite fact in this whole story. As Lord Chamberlain, Henry Carey became the patron of the Lord Chamberlain’s Men, William Shakespeare’s acting company. Mary Boleyn’s son was Shakespeare’s patron. I love that.

As he lay dying in 1596, Elizabeth offered him the Boleyn earldom of Ormond that his family had long wanted. He turned it down. He died on July 23, 1596, and Elizabeth also paid for his burial in Westminster Abbey.

Is the Royal Family Descended From Mary Boleyn?

Yes. Through her daughter Catherine, Mary is an ancestor of Elizabeth Bowes-Lyon, the Queen Mother, which makes her a forebear of Queen Elizabeth II and King Charles III.

It doesn’t stop there. Diana, Princess of Wales, descended from Mary’s son Henry Carey. So Prince William and Prince Harry carry Mary Boleyn’s blood twice over, once from each parent.

Anne Boleyn’s line ended with Elizabeth I in 1603, but Mary’s runs straight to the throne today.

The Boleyn Who Got Away

Anne wanted a crown and got one, for a thousand days. George wanted power and got the block. Mary wanted a quiet life with a man who loved her, and she got that too.

She never wore a crown or held any real power, but she outlived the brother and sister who did, and her children and grandchildren filled the court of the queen who should have been her rival’s legacy. Of the three Boleyn children, Mary won.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mary Boleyn

How old was Mary Boleyn when she became Henry VIII’s mistress?

When Mary Boleyn became Henry VIII’s mistress, most historians believe, she was in her early twenties when her affair with Henry VIII began. The best evidence points to the years between about 1522 and 1525. She was already married to William Carey, a member of the king’s privy chamber, at the time. She was not a young teenager, as some retellings claim.

Did Mary Boleyn have children with Henry VIII?

No one knows whether Mary Boleyn had children with Henry VIII. She had two children, Catherine Carey around 1524 and Henry Carey in 1526, while she was married to William Carey and during the years of her affair with the king. Henry VIII never acknowledged either child. In 1535, one witness claimed young Henry Carey was the king’s son, but the witness was unreliable.

Was Mary Boleyn older than Anne Boleyn?

Most historians believe Mary Boleyn was older than Anne Boleyn. She married first, in 1520, and in 1597 her grandson claimed the Boleyn earldom of Ormond because Mary was the elder daughter. If Anne had been older, Queen Elizabeth I would have inherited that claim. A minority of historians still argue that Anne was older.

Who did Mary Boleyn marry?

Mary Boleyn married twice. She married William Carey, a courtier in Henry VIII’s privy chamber, on February 4, 1520. He died of the sweating sickness in 1528. In 1534, she secretly married William Stafford, a soldier with little money. The marriage angered Queen Anne, and Mary was banished from court.

How did Mary Boleyn die?

No record survives of how Mary Boleyn died. She died in July 1543, aged about 44, probably at Rochford Hall in Essex. Her burial place is also unknown, and there is no tomb or memorial to her. She outlived both her siblings, Anne and George, who were executed in 1536.

Is King Charles III descended from Mary Boleyn?

Yes. King Charles III descends from Mary Boleyn through his grandmother, Elizabeth Bowes-Lyon, the Queen Mother, whose family traced back to Mary’s daughter Catherine Carey. Diana, Princess of Wales, also descended from Mary through her son Henry Carey. That gives Prince William and Prince Harry two separate lines of descent from Mary Boleyn.

Promotional banner for a Medieval Survival Quiz with bold text asking, "Would You Survive the Middle Ages?" and "Which Medieval Class Would You Belong To? Prove Thy Worth." Features vintage-style illustrations of a knight, a noblewoman, an archer, and other medieval figures, along with a scroll-shaped button reading "Take the Quiz."